Revisions and Immutability

Lorenzo DeeNovember 14th, 2018Last Updated: November 14th, 2018

0 29 3 minutes read

Here’s a brief post. I’m not sure how to start it. It’s one of those “why didn’t I think of that” moments while reviewing some existing code. Due to NDAs, I cannot share the actual code. It has something to do with handling revisions. The closest thing I can relate to is how WordPress (WP) handles blog posts and revisions.

In WP, the wp_insert_post function inserts or updates a post. It checks the ID field to determine if it will carry out an INSERT or an UPDATE. If the post is being updated, it checks if changes were made. If so, a revision is saved. A limit for the number of revisions to keep can be set. If so, the oldest ones are deleted.

This sounds like something that can be modeled as a rich domain entity. Here’s a first try.

@Entity
... class Post {
    @Id @GeneratedValue ... id;
    ... name;
    ... title;
    ... content;
    ... excerpt;
    ... status; // e.g. 'draft', 'publish', 'inherit'
    ... type; // e.g. 'post', 'revision'
    @OneToMany @JoinColumn(name="parent_post_id") ... List<Post> revisions;
    ...
    // setters and getters
}

Post post = new Post();
post.setTitle("Lorem Ipsum");
post.setContent("...");
// save post
...
post = // retrieve existing post for updates
post.setContent("..."); // how can we ensure that revision is created?

In the first try, the setter methods pose a challenge to ensuring that a revision is created when the post is updated. Let’s give it another try. Here’s our second try.

// Immutable class
@Embeddable
... class PostData {
    ... title;
    ... content;
    ... excerpt;
    // getters only
    ... getTitle() { return title; }
    ... getContent() { return content; }
    ... getExcerpt() { return excerpt; }
    // equals() method to compare with another post data
    // to see if there are changes
}

@Entity
... class Post {
    @Id @GeneratedValue ... id;
    ... name; // for a revision, will contain parent ID and revision #
    @Embedded ... PostData postData; // read-only
    ... status; // e.g. 'draft', 'published', 'inherit'
    ... type; // e.g. 'post', 'revision'
    @OneToMany @JoinColumn(name="parent_post_id") ... List<Post> revisions;
    ...
    ... getTitle() { return this.postData.getTitle(); }
    ... getContent() { return this.postData.getContent(); }
    ... getExcerpt() { return this.postData.getExcerpt(); }
    ... getName() { return name; }
}

This is when I got my “why didn’t I think of that” moment!

Note how we encapsulated the post data into its own type — PostData. It is immutable. This makes it possible to ensure that a revision is created when the post is updated.

PostData postData = new PostData("Lorem Ipsum", "...", "...");
Post post = new Post(postData);
// save post
...
post = // retrieve existing post for updates
// post.setContent("..."); // not possible
post.updateData(new PostData("...", "...", "...")); // ensure that revision is created

And here’s how we create revisions.

@Entity
... class Post {
    ...
    @Embedded ... PostData postData; // read-only
    ...
    @OneToMany @JoinColumn(name="parent_post_id") ... List<Post> revisions;
    ...
    public Post(PostData postData) {
        this(postData, null);
    }
    /* package private */ Post(PostData postData, Post parent) {
        if (postData == null) {
            throw new IllegalArgumentException(...);
        }
        this.postData = postData;
        if (parent == null) {
            this.type = "post";
            this.status = "draft";
            this.name = null;
            this.revisions = new ArrayList<>();
        } else {
            this.type = "revision";
            this.status = "inherit";
            this.name = "" + parent.getId() + "-revision" + (parent.getRevisionsCount() + 1);
            this.revisions = null;
        }
        ...
    }
    ...
    ... void updateData(PostData newPostData) {
        if (this.postData.equals(newPostData)) {
            // no changes, no revisions added
            return;
        }
        ...
        // creates a revision
        PostData beforePostData = this.postData;
        this.revisions.add(0, new Post(beforePostData, this));
        // store latest changes
        this.postData = newPostData;
        // limit to number of revisions to keep
        if (this.revisions.size() > ...) {
            // delete the excess ones
            for (...) {
                this.revisions.remove(this.revisions.size() - 1);
            }
        }
        ...
    }
    ...
}

Like I said, this one is a brief post. Let me know in the comments below if it’s something you’ve seen before, or, just like me, it gave you a “why didn’t I think of that” moment.

Published on Java Code Geeks with permission by Lorenzo Dee, partner at our JCG program. See the original article here: Revisions and Immutability

Opinions expressed by Java Code Geeks contributors are their own.